Key for the identification of the known mines of British
insects (Diptera and non-Diptera) recorded on Ulmus
|
1a > Leaf-miner and case-bearer: The larva lives outside the mine, protected by a case, and feeds on the underlying plant tissues via a hole cut in the epidermis. From that point it eats away as much leaf tissue as it can reach without fully entering the mine. Mine does not contain frass (Coleophora species) |
2 |
1b > Bark-miner or leaf-miner, but not a case-bearer: The larva lives mainly inside the mine. Mine usually contains frass. In later instars the larva may live sandwiched between two more or less circular sections cut from the leaf. |
3 |
2a > Leaf-miner
and case-bearer: The larva initially forms a gallery along the
midrib, which then goes out along a vein. The end of this gallery
is then excised to construct the first case. It then feeds close
to this and makes several small mines.
The
final case is a small, laterally compressed, squat, spatulate leaf
case of 5-6 mm. The dorsal keel has some serrations, remnants of
the leaf margin out of which the case was cut. The rear is twovalved,
and remarkably broad. The mouth angle is 0-10°.
The
description and illustration of the final case in Emmet et al. (1996a)
is not quite clear. They depict a rather slender case, and state
that the mouth angle is 30°. But, as the only illustration in
the other literature that would agree with the British badiipennella,
they refer to Hering (1957a, fig. 701): this illustration, however,
has no resemblance to their own figure, and has a mouth angle of
c. 0°.
Emmet
et al. write that the larva begins its life by making a gallery
of 10-15 mm that runs from the midrib along a side vein; out if
this mine the first youth case is excised. |
|
On Ulmus in Britain and Acer campestre, Acer platanoides,
Corylus avellana, Fraxinus, Ulmus glabra, Ulmus minor and Ulmus x hollandica elsewhere.
Locally distributed throughout much of England. Widespread in
continental Europe.
|
Coleophora
badiipennella (Duponchel, 1843) [Lepidoptera: Coleophoridae]. |
2b > Leaf-miner
and case-bearer: This species produces a distinctive larval case in its later stages
with a noticeably serrated upper edge, and affixed almost parallel
to the leaf surface. The larvae overwinter when small and recommence
feeding in late spring.
Oviposition
generally in a vein axil. From there a short, relatively wide corridor
is made that quickly widens into an elliptical blotch. Much of the
frass is ejected through the hole that the larva has made to bore
itself into the leaf (in C.
badiipennella, on the same host plant, the frass remains
within the mine. This blotch is excised to make the juvenile case.
The full grown larva lives in a brown spatulate leaf case of 9-11.5
mm; its rear end is bivalved. Mouth angle 0°-20°; just behind
the mouth the case shows a conspicuous bend. |
|
|
On Ulmus in Britain and elsewhere. Distributed mainly in
the south and south-east of England. Widespread in continental
Europe.
|
Coleophora
limosipennella (Duponchel, 1843) [Lepidoptera: Coleophoridae]. |
2c > Leaf-miner
and case-bearer: The larva feeds by inserting its head into small mines it creates
on the leaves of birch, elm, alder, or hazel. Occasionally it is
found feeding on other trees, or on herbaceous plants onto which
it has accidentally Fallén. It forms two cases during its larval
life. The first case is initially curved, smooth, laterally compressed
with a bivalved anal opening, and about 2 mm long in September.
During October it feeds, and adds a few rough collars of larval
material around the oral opening. After hibernation, it feeds again
in April and early May, adding more protruding collars until they
equal or exceed the original smooth part of the case. At the same
time, it expands the case girth by the creation of a silk gusset
ventrally. The second case, 6 or 7 mm long, is formed in May, leaving
the vacated first case attached to its last feeding mine. The new
case is tubular with a trivalved crimp at the anal opening. The
dorsum is formed from the edge of the leaf from which the case was
cut. This results in a more or less serrated dorsal keel, depending
on the plant species and the individual piece of leaf used. Considerable
variation in the degree of serration can be found, even among specimens
off the same tree. The case colour varies with food plant, from
yellowish brown on birch, darkening through elm and hazel to dark
brown on alder.
The
strongly curved young case is is a composite leaf case, the adult
case is a tubular leaf case. The adult case is bivalved, about 7
mm in length; the mouth angle is around 30°. The case is straw
coloured and almost always has a toothed dorsal keel (remnant of
the margin of the leaf from which the case was cut). Neither larvae
or cases of C.
coracipennella, prunifoliae, serratella and spinella can be
separated; from serratella. |
|
|
On Alnus, Betula, Corylus, Ulmus and Sorbus in Britain plus Carpinus, Mespilus,
Ostrya, Hippophae, Ribes, Myrica, Forsythia, Amelanchier, Chaenomeles,
Cotoneaster, Crataegus, Cydonia, Eriobotrya, Malus, Prunus, Sorbus,
Spiraea, Populus and Salix elsewhere. This is probably the commonest species of British
coleophorid, and is found throughout the British Isles. Widespread
in continental Europe.
|
Coleophora
serratella (Linnaeus 1761) [Lepidoptera: Coleophoridae]. |
2d > Leaf-miner
and case-bearer: The larva feeds on a wide range of trees, shrubs and herbs, favouring
Rosaceae, but not exclusively. The fully developed cased larva may
be found active in October and again, after winter diapause, in
April. Cases, about 6 mm, of diapausing larvae may be found through
winter, fixed to a tree or fence post. The dorsal surface of the
case is usually covered in leaf fragments, but they can sometimes
be worn off almost smooth. The ventral surface is swollen at the
middle and has a keel, which usually bends upwards at the posterior.
The cases of C. ahenella (on Rhamnus, Frangula, Viburnum and Cornus) and C.
potentillae (case less swollen, keel not bent up, resting
position less prone) are very similar.
Brownish
lobe case that lies almost flat on the leaf, either on the upper
or on the lower side. Case widest about the middle. Ventrally there
is a distinct keel. Mouth angle 0°. Full depth mines rather
large. The flaps of cuticular tissue that serve to enlarge the case
are cut out of the upper epidermis. (contrary to C.
ahenella and C.
potentillae, that use tissue from the lower epidermis).
The removal of these tissue flaps creates holes that are much larger
than those that serve as the entrance to the mine. |
|

Coleophora violacea larva, lateral
Image: © Willem Ellis (Bladmineerders van Europa) |
Polyphagous. On numerous genera and species in several plant families, including Ulmus, in Britain and elsewhere. Widespread in Britain
and continental Europe.
|
Coleophora
violaceae (Ström 1783) [Lepidoptera: Coleophoridae]. |
3a > Bark-miner: The long mine is found in the bark of thin branches of Elm. Little
known of the life history. |
|
On Ulmus in Britain. In Britain discovered in 1994 from
Hunts. Widespread in continental Europe.
|
Ectoedemia
amani Svensson, 1966 [Lepidoptera: Nepticulidae]. |
3b > Leaf-miner: A
very clear blotch, without preceding corridor, usually harbouring
several crimson marbled larvae. The mine mostly begins near the
base of the midrib. Most frass is ejected from the mine, but some
of the grains are trapped in a loose spinning below the leaf, that
has been made by the larvae during excursions. The larvae can leave
their mine and restart elsewhere. The larvae hibernate individually in a discoid
cocoon. The larva overwinters
within a cocoon spun in the leaf. |
|
|
On Betula, but not yet on Ulmus, in Britain
plus Alnus, Betula nana, Betula pendula and Ulmus minor elsewhere. Widespread in Scotland and continental Europe.
|
Atemelia
torquatella (Lienig & Zeller, 1846) [Lepidoptera: Yponomeutidae]. |
3c > Leaf-miner: Winding full depth corridor up to 15 mm long with a long larval
chamber. Black frass in a central line, broad, but leaving a clear
zone at either side. Characteristically the corridor has 2-4 short,
frass-free, side branches (diverticula) occurring at points where
the main corridor makes a sharp turn. The first one often is interparenchymatous
tissue and difficult to see; the following turns usually have opening
in the lower epidermis at their end. Older larvae live free on the
leaf, creating windows; the exit hole is in the underside of the
leaf. The larva pupates in an oval cocoon. |
|
On Ulmus, but not yet on Ulmus, in Britain
and elsewhere. Southern half of England. Widespread in continental
Europe.
|
Bucculatrix
albedinella (Zeller, 1839) [Lepidoptera: Bucculatricidae]. |
3d > Leaf-miner: Starts
as a contorted frass-filled gallery, between the midrib and vein.
Later the gallery, with broken black frass, follows a vein before
turning away. The final mine is 11-15 mm long..
Oviposition
on the leaf underside, generally in the axil of the midrib and a
thick lateral vein. The very first part of the mine is so strongly
contorted that sometimes a tiny secondary blotch originates, filled
with black frass. Then follows a straight corridor of maximally
15 mm, almost completely filled with frass, mostly closely following
a vein. Just before the larva is about to leave the mine (through
an exit hole in the leaf underside) it turns away from the vein. Pupa dark blackish brown, in a grey-black, ribbed cocoon (Langmaid, Porter
and Collins, 2007). |
|
On Ulmus in Britain and elsewhere. Discovered
in 2006 in Surrey. Widespread in continental Europe.
|
Bucculatrix
ulmifoliae M. Hering 1931 [Lepidoptera:
Bucculatricidae]. |
3e > Leaf-miner: A
rather large, clear, partly full depth blotch that begins in the
axil of a thick lateral vein. Often the ovipostion leaves a greyish-green
scar. Generally several mines in a leaf. The mine expands within
the confines of the midrib and two lateral veins; only close to
the leaf margin, where the lateral veins are thin, the mine may
trespass over a vein.
The larvae of sawflies have at least six thoracic legs (although they may be reduced or absent), a head capsule and chewing mouthparts with opposable mandibles but no abdominal legs. |
|
|
On Alnus, Betula and Ulmus in Britain and elsewhere. Recorded in Britain and the Republic
of Ireland. Widespread in continental Europe.
|
Fenusa
pumila Leach, 1817 [Hymenoptera: Tenthredinidae]. |
3f > Leaf-miner: A long, whitish smoothly-curved upper-surface mine with broken black
frass.
Oviposition
is by means of an ovipositor; what remains is a small scar: no egg
shell is visible at the start of the mine. From here a long, sometimes
very long, slender, full depth corridor winds throught the leaf,
not steered by leaf margin or the leaf venation. The midrib is crossed
effortless; the corridor frequently also crosses
itself; the section of the leaf cut off then usally turns brown
and dies off. Frass in a narrow central line. The larva vacates
the mine prior to pupation through an exit in the upper epidermis.
The vacated larval chamber is proportionally much
longer than in the case of Stigmella mines ( > 3 x longer
than broad). Pupation in a silken cocoon suspended from threads attached to food plant
or other vegetation. |
|
|
Polyphagous. On numerous genera and species in several plant families, including Ulmus, in Britain. On numerous genera and species in several plant families, but not Ulmus elsewhere. Widespread
in Britain and continental Europe. Also recorded in the Republic
of Ireland.
|
Lyonetia
clerkella (Linnaeus, 1758) [Lepidoptera: Lyonetiidae]. |
3g > Leaf-miner: Oviposition in the underside of the midrib; here an extensive scar
remains visible. From this point a full depth corridor runs towards
the leaf tip, where it widens to a blotch. The larva eventually
pupates in a globular cocoon, made inside the mine. Because the
mine is made at a time the leaf still is unfolding, the leaf can
be strongly disfigured. |
|
|
|
On Ulmus in Britain and elsewhere. Widespread in Britain.
Also recorded in the Republic of Ireland. Widespread in continental
Europe.
|
Orchestes
alni (Linnaeus, 1758) [Coleoptera: Curculionidae]. |
3h > Leaf-miner: The mine is oval, sometimes crossing veins. The lower epidermis
with several strong creases.
Along
with P. tristrigella,
this species feeds on elm, although not usually on wych elm like
that species. However the two mines are quite different - schreberella forming a rounded mine and tristrigella a longer, narrower tube-like
mine.
Short,
roundish to oval, somewhat inflated, lower surface tentiform mine,
often crossing a lateral vein. Epidermis with several length folds. Dark brown pupa in a tough, greenish cocoon; the cocoon lies
free in the mine, and its wall is not encrusted with frass. |
|
|
On Ulmus in Britain and ? Carpinus and Ulmus elsewhere. Mainly in the southern half of England and Wales. Widespread
in continental Europe.
|
Phyllonorycter
schreberella (Fabricius, 1781) [Lepidoptera:
Gracillariidae]. |
3i > Leaf-miner: The mine is long and narrow, tubular, caused by strong contraction.
The lower epidermis with several strong creases.
Long, lower-surface
tubular tentiform mine between two lateral veins, in many cases
from midrib to leaf margin. Lower epidermis with several long folds
close together. Pupa light brown, in tough brown papery coccoon
that is attached to the lower epidermis. All frass in a mass in
one corner of the mine. |
|

Phyllonorycter tristrigella larva, dorsal
Image: © Willem Ellis (Bladmineerders van Europa) |
|
On Ulmus in Britain and elsewhere. Relatively common in
mainland Britain northwards to southern Scotland. Also recorded
in the Republic of Ireland. Widespread in continental Europe.
|
Phyllonorycter
tristrigella (Haworth, 1828) [Lepidoptera: Gracillaridae]. |
3j > Leaf-miner: The frass is dispersed in early part of mine.
Oviposition
at upper or lower surface. Rather slender corridor mine, hardly
widened in the end. The corridor often follows the leaf margin for
some distance. The first section of the corridor is almost entirely
filled with frass. Frass in the later part of the mine in more or
less clear coils. Pupation external; exit slit invariably in upper
epidermis. |
|
|
On Ulmus in Britain and elsewhere. Distributed throughout
the British Isles. Widespread in continental Europe.
|
Stigmella
lemniscella (Zeller, 1839) [Lepidoptera: Nepticulidae]. |
3k > Leaf-miner: The frass is linear in early part of mine.
Egg
at the underside of the leaf, generally near a vein. The mine is
s slender corridor. Frass in its first part in a narrow central
line. The frass pattern in the later segment is very variable: sometimes
in a narrow central line, sometimes broadly dispersed or even coiled.
Especially in the latter case confusion with St. lemniscella is
hard to avoid. The only reliable character that remains then is
that the exit slit is in the lower epidermis. |
|
On Ulmus in Britain and elsewhere. Widespread in England.
Also recorded in the Republic of Ireland. Widespread in continental
Europe.
|
Stigmella
ulmivora (Fologne, 1860) [Lepidoptera: Nepticulidae]. |
3l > Leaf-miner: A contorted, “gut”-shaped gallery. The fresh frass is reddish in
colour.
Very
compact upper or lower side mine; a strongly contorted corridor
in intestine-like, zigzagging loops; only the very last part of
the corridor is free. Frass in the first and in the final part of
the mine black, warm brown and coiled in the central section, and,
except for the last section, occupying the entire width of the corridor.
Fresh mines have a striking red brown colour. |
|
On Ulmus in Britain and elsewhere. Widespread in the southern
half of England. Widespread in continental Europe.
|
Stigmella
viscerella (Stainton, 1853) [Lepidoptera: Nepticulidae]. |
3m > Leaf-miner: Full depth blotch, invariably beginning at the leaf tip or the tip
of a leaf lobe or tooth. Oviposition site covered by a black, shining
drop of hardened secretion. Frass generally in long threads, but
sometimes in elongated granules. Pupation in the mine, not in a cocoon. |
|
|
On Corylus avellana, but not yet on Ulmus,
in Britain. On several genera and species in several
plant families including Ulmus elsewhere. Widespread in
Britain and continental Europe.
|
Trachys
minutus (Linnaeus, 1758) [Coleoptera: Buprestidae]. |
3n > Leaf
mine: Very clear blotch, containing a yellow white larva. The final mine may occupy a sizable part of the leaf. The mine usually starts in a vein axil, never at the leaf margin (Liston, 1994a); in large leaves the mine remains confined between to lateral veins. Frass in black grains, initially often in long pearl chains, in older mines in loose grains.
The larvae of sawflies have at least six thoracic legs (although they may be reduced or absent), a head capsule and chewing mouthparts with opposable mandibles but no abdominal legs. |
|
|
On Ulmus species in England and elsewhere. Widespread in Britain and continental Europe.
|
Fenusa ulmi Sundevall, 1847 [Hymenoptera: Tenthredinidae]. |